Romance, “You Must Remember This (Expanded Edition)” (Ecstatic 2020/2025)
Newly issued on vinyl in remastered and expanded form (and almost instantly sold out), 2020’s You Must Remember This was the mixtape that first introduced this anonymous London-based project to the world. Since then, the project has evolved considerably and released several collaborations with both Ecstatic co-founder Alessio Natalizia (Not Waving) and long-time David Lynch collaborator Dean Hurley.
Notably, that latter union already seemed preordained by fate even at this early stage, as both Mulholland Drive and Angelo Badalementi are pretty obvious touchstones, but Romance’s plunderphonic vision of tape music also feels equally informed by minimalist loop-weavers like Celer and William Basinski and the haunted luxury hotel ambiance of Richard Chartier’s Pinkcourtesyphone project. The sublime moods that this mysterious composer conjures up are distinctly their own, however, as these dreamlike vignettes re-envision smudged, slow-motion melancholy as something considerably more sensuous and sexy than usual.
Aside from the new format, the remastering job by Demdike Stare’s Miles Whittaker, and the addition of two additional pieces not included on the original cassette, this reissue is also significant for finally revealing the album’s song titles. That said, I use the word “song” loosely here, as the album is essentially a series of loop-driven mood pieces that have been stitched together into an immersive, pink-hued fantasia.
Notably, one of the “new” pieces borrows its title from The Smiths’ lovesick classic “Please, Please, Please Let Me Get What I Want,” which nods towards Romance’s genuine and well-documented fondness for pop music love songs both cool and otherwise (a trait that manifested itself most strongly on 2022’s Celine Dion-inspired In My Hour of Weakness, I Found a Sweetness EP).
Elsewhere, the album’s title provides yet another clue to one of Romance’s central inspirations, as it is a reference to the first line of “As Time Goes By” from Casablanca. It may also be an allusion to Karina Longworth’s long-running podcast of the same name, as the secret and forgotten history of Hollywood definitely seems like it would be of great interest to this enigmatic artist. Classic Hollywood film soundtracks loom very large in Romance’s world.
As Ecstatic eloquently observed back in 2020, this album straddles “the Warholian line of high / low culture,” as Romance elegantly blurs the “winsome emotive nostalgia of Hollywood symphonic soundtracks” with ostensibly kitschy borrowings from pop music to craft a wonderfully pulp/noir-informed “psychotropic, time-smearing mixtape” of “chopped & screwed romantic classical and new age ballads.”
To my ears, Romance’s “classic Hollywood” side is best represented by the sensuously swooning, flickering, and endlessly restarting string loops of the opening “Come Closer,” but that piece is also a prime example of why future Romance albums would surpass this one, as the grandeur and achingly beautiful delirium of that piece only lasts for a minute and half before dissolving into the next piece. Maddening brevity aside, however, “Come Closer” is rapturously beautiful while it lasts, as Romance definitely knows how to weave pure magic from little more than an insistently looping fragment of melody.
Thankfully, however, there are a few more divergent gems that linger around long enough to make a deeper impression. My favorite of the lot is “Just Like Me,” which casts a seductive, slow-motion spell of unintelligibly time-stretched and murmuring vocal melodies, but I am also quite fond of the similarly glacial “Songbird,” which combines Badalementi-esque synths and hallucinatory chimes with a skeletal groove of clicks, pops, and cymbals distilled to little more than rhythmic hiss and sizzle.
The piece that best captures this album’s essence, however, is the spectral, hiss-soaked, and decidedly uneasy ambiance of “And So To Sleep Again.” The piece’s central motif is a murky, stammering, and subtly hallucinatory minor key piano theme, which departs from the rest of the album’s smudgy, soft-focus sensuality and blissed-out ambient interludes to feel like a séance in which a prophecy of impending doom supernaturally bleeds though a veil of hissing static. It acts as a fleeting and chill-inducing shadow that suggests that the story is unlikely to end well for our hypothetical starry-eyed ingénue despite the warm, poignant beauty and romance that otherwise pervades the album.
To circle back to David Lynch once more, the album resembles a version of Mullholland Drive that ends long before things start to get truly dark, but mingles flickering and elusive memories of tangled sheets, luxurious hotels, soft-focus eroticism, and Hollywood glamor with enough ephemeral glimpses of curdled dissonance to suggest that this languorously sexy, and glittering dreamworld is just as precarious and fleeting as an actual dream.
That is quite a subtly sophisticated and emotionally complex world for a debut album to conjure, so it is easy to see why You Must Remember This deserved a deluxe reissue such as this one. While I do think that this project fitfully continued to get better and better with successive releases, Romance’s vision was already distinctive, immersive, and fully formed even at this early stage. Moreover, the two new pieces make this incarnation an unexpectedly significant improvement upon the (already wonderful) original, as the billowing dream fog and chimes of the new closer make for a sublimely beautiful finale. This album is one hell of a immersive and mesmerizing delirium.
Listen here.
